Facebook and Twitter could face £40m fines for not removing hate speech

Facebook and Twitter could face £40m fines for not removing hate speech

European Jewish leader welcomes proposal to penalise social media sites up to £43 million for failing to tackle hate

Germany’s justice minister has proposed fines of up to 50 million euro (£43.8 million) for social networking sites that fail to swiftly remove illegal content, such as hate speech or defamatory “fake news”.

The plan marks a further step in Germany’s attempt to impose its strict domestic laws against incitement on the free-wheeling world of online chatter.

Justice minister Heiko Maas, a member of the centre-left Social Democratic Party, said social media companies had already taken voluntary steps to crack down on hate crimes that have resulted in improvements.

“This isn’t sufficient yet,” Mr Maas said, citing research that he said showed Twitter deletes just 1% of illegal content flagged by users, while Facebook deletes 39%.

The proposal would require companies to provide a round-the-clock service for users to flag illegal content, which would have to be removed by the site within seven days.

Robert Singer, the chief executive of the World Jewish Congress, praised the Maas proposal.

“The internet is awash with hateful content, a lot of which is incitement to hatred and violence. Currently, it often takes providers far too long to remove or block such content,” he said.

“It’s important that the internet companies and politicians take this problem seriously, and we commend Germany for taking the lead on this.”

The Community Security Trust said: “We have repeatedly urged social media companies to ensure that their understanding of hate speech meets the expectations of their users, because the failure to remove blatantly antisemitic content like this video gives the damaging message that antisemitism is welcome on their platforms. We will continue to work with all the platforms to help them improve their understanding of antisemitism and their processes for identifying and removing it.”

The proposal will not affect media outlets already covered by other German laws, said Philip Scholz, a justice ministry spokesman.

A bill could go before politicians ahead of Germany’s general election in September, though such a timetable was “ambitious”, he said.

All copies of the content would also have to be deleted and social media companies would need to publish a quarterly report detailing how they have dealt with such material.

Sites would also have to nominate a person responsible for handling complaints, who could face fines of up to five million euro (£4.3 million) personally if the company fails to abide by mandatory standards.

Mr Maas said the measures, which will become part of a bill to be put before parliament, would not restrict freedom of speech that already exists in Germany and there were no plans to create a “truth commission” against so-called fake news.

But he noted that fake news could constitute illegal content “if it constitutes slander, defamation or libel”.

Facebook said it would examine the proposal.

“We have clear rules against hate speech and are working hard to remove such content from our platform,” the company said in a statement, adding it was working with the government to tackle the issue.

However, Facebook said tests it commissioned showed higher rates of removal than those cited by Mr Maas.

Facebook also said it had taken measures to train staff in how to deal with the legal situation in Germany and expects to have 700 people in Berlin examining flagged content by the end of the year.

Twitter declined to comment directly on the proposal, but noted that it had taken a number of measures in recent months designed to prevent abuse and allow users to filter unwanted content.


Germany poses a particular problem for US-owned social networking sites accustomed to American standards of free speech.

Due to its Nazi past, Germany bans public Holocaust denial and any overt promotion of racism.

The issue has come to the fore amid the recent influx of migrants to Germany, which has sparked a backlash among some Germans, including a rise in online vitriol.



read more: