Ask The Rabbi – 28/11/2013

Ask The Rabbi – 28/11/2013

Dear Rabbi,

All my life I used candles for Chanukah. This year I am married and my husband insists we use oil. It’s messy and I want to know if it really makes any difference. A light is a light after all.



Dear Sandra,

You see! That’s what happens when you don’t cover the fine print on your dates. Every potential couple ought to be asking one another what they use on Chanukah and if there is a clash of custom that should be a deal breaker. Seriously?!

Firstly, he is lighting, not you. As his wife, you fulfil your obligation with him. Secondly, as a general rule, the husband’s customs prevail: i.e if he is Sephardi and you are Ashkenazi, you’ll eat rice on Pesach, but not vice versa. Finally, his time-hallowed custom versus your cleanliness concern, which do you think should take precedence? And for what it’s worth – no, a light is not a light. Jewish law does stipulate that the ideal mitzvah is celebrated with oil just as the miracle all those years ago occurred with oil. So why don’t you give your husband a really nice present on your first Chanukah together as newlyweds – and let him light with oil.

Oh, and if you have a similar crisis on Purim because he wants prune hamentashen and you insist on jam ones, don’t write to me – get professional help.[divider]

Dear Rabbi,

As a Sephardi Jew, our custom is to have a special celebration feast on Chanukah and I’m wondering why Ashkenazim don’t. I get invited to friends’ and it is always: latkes, doughnuts and drinks, but never a proper meal.



Dear Amir,

The difference of opinion is brought in Jewish law, and while it is recommended for Ashkenazim to do the same, it is simply a suggestion.

The festive meal is to commemorate the victory in battle against the Greek army when God “gave the many into the hands of the few, and the strong into the hands of the weak,” as we note in our service.

But the main thrust of the Chanukah celebrations is really the miracle of the oil, which lasted eight days, despite there being only just enough for one. There is really something deeper at play in the standoff between the Greeks and the Jews: here we have a meeting of two cultures, with so much to share and contribute to the world together.

The Greek asks: “OK so tell me about your rituals?” The Jew replies: “We don’t eat milk with meat.” Greek: “Why not?” Jew: “God says so.”

Greek: “For what reason?”

Jew: “Reason? He needs a reason? For the same reason He created heaven and earth! He decided He would like a world where there would be milk and meat and He would tell people: ‘Don’t eat that milk and meat together!’ and they would listen.”

Greek: “That makes no sense. That’s not a reason!”

And here we get to the crux: to the Greek, everything has to make sense. But the Jew submits even if he is unable to comprehend. That’s why the Greeks did not forbid Jewish practice altogether. Initially, they forbade only the practices they saw as irrational; the practices done simply because Jews believe they have a relationship with a Being higher than reason; such as Shabbat, kashrut and circumcision. That the Greeks could not tolerate. The single biggest problem with Jews through the ages is the reluctance to accept the mission irrespective of our ability to comprehend.

To do what you have to do simply because it has to be done – even if it doesn’t appeal to you, even if it breaches your comfort zone, even if you think you know better – to do it or accept it simply because God said so and that is how we connect to Him. That is the victory of Chanukah as it was then and as it relates to us as Jews today. The miracle of the oil is undeniably supernatural, and attests to the underlying victory of the supra-rational devotion of the Jew. This was the real miracle then and is the miracle of our survival against the odds throughout the ages. That’s what we celebrate.[divider]

Dear Rabbi,

Is there a source for Chanukah presents or is it just copied from Christmas?



Dear Gerald

On the first morning of Chanukah my wife said she dreamt I gave her a diamond necklace as a Chanukah gift. “What do you think it means?” she asked. I said: “You’ll find out tonight!” I handed her a small, specially gift-wrapped box. She opened it excitedly and found inside… a book: Freud’s The Interpretation of Dreams. There is no source for gift-giving on Chanukah per se. It seems this custom was adopted in Europe partially in response to our non-Jewish neighbours celebrating their holiday with gifts under a pine tree. It is, however, an age-old custom to give money to children on Chanukah, so we can teach them to give some of it to charity.

Chanukah is from the root word chinuch meaning education, and as Jewish education came under threat in the Chanukah story, we look to incentivise and enhance it, especially on Chanukah. Gift giving is then a by-product of that and is okay as long as it’s given with the right intent, such that the act of giving speaks louder than the gift itself.[divider]

• Read Rabbi Schochet’s blog at or follow him on Twitter at @RabbiYYS

read more: