In an unusual move, a Lithuanian court voided the local Jewish community’s April internal elections, challenging the current leadership’s legal authority.
The Dec. 21 ruling by Vilnius District Court, which is the first of its kind in years in Europe, is the latest development in the fight against what many Lithuanian Jews consider a power grab by the community’s president, Faina Kukliansky, and may affect for her ability both to continue to represent members of her community and to administer millions of dollars given to that community by the government as restitution for the Holocaust.
The ruling by Judge Rima Bražinskienė, which was translated by the site Defending History, was in a lawsuit filed earlier this year by the Vilnius Jewish Community against Kukliansky’s Jewish Community of Lithuania, which is a national umbrella group for all of the country’s Jewish communities, known also as LBZ.
The lawsuit followed a mid-campaign rule change by the LBZ board. Amid growing resentment against Kukliansky over alleged corruption and nepotism — which she has denied – the board she governs decided to replace its proportional voting system with one that gives each member organisation one vote.
The change disenfranchised the 2,200 members of the Vilnius Jewish Community, by far the country’s largest, leading to Kukliansky’s re-election. When a critic of Kukliansky, Simonas Gurevicius, was elected head of the Vilnius Jewish Community in May, LZB voided that election, saying that the voters were “mainly Russian speakers calling themselves Jews, with only a minority of people with Litvak blood.”
The statement, for which LZB later apologised, prompted critics to say LZB under Kukliansky was stoking ethnic tensions and flagging some Jews as agents of Russia in a country where many people and politicians resent Russia’s expansionist tendencies.
The controversial LZB statement noted the vote took place while “military exercises are currently underway rehearsing the scenario of Lithuania and Poland under attack.”
Following the District Court ruling, LZB in a statement criticized the court’s ruling as “referring neither to the imperative of the law ensuring the right and equality of decision-makers of all members of the association” nor provisions ensuring communal discretion. It did not say whether LZB will hold a new election, as the Vilnius Jewish Community urged LZB to do following the ruling. “Internal disagreements that were opened up to publicly will add honour to no one, will not reduce the manifestations of anti-Semitism, will not destroy the stereotypes and will not facilitate meaningful work for the benefit of members of the community. It is a shame that a small Jewish community is split up where it would be possible to consolidate efforts to achieve higher goals – the fight against anti-Semitism.”
In the background of this legal fight, LZB is also facing criticism for going a long with a government plan to build a convention centre on what used to be a large cemetery in Vilnius. Soviets destroyed the Piramont Cemetery decades ago but some rabbis and Jewish community members say construction on the site that still contains the remains of thousands of Jewish bodies would violate Jewish religious laws.
But other rabbis and LZB maintain the site intended for the conference centre does not contain human remains.
Kukliansky is also the co-chairperson of the Goodwill Foundation, which was set up in 2011 to administer restitution funds to the tune of roughly £30m ($40 million).